Family Yoga with Natasha

Why “Just Take a Deep Breath” Often Doesn’t Work (And What Actually Helps)

“Take a deep breath.”

It’s one of the most common pieces of advice we hear…. to support children and ourselves, told to anyone who looks overwhelmed, angry or having a tough time.

And while it’s usually said with care, compassion, and good intention… it so often falls flat.

You’ve probably seen it.
You suggest a deep breath and your child:
– breathes in as fast as they can
– tenses their shoulders
– sucks their belly in
– gets more frustrated
– or looks at you like you’ve completely missed the point

And the truth is….you haven’t done anything wrong.

The problem isn’t the breathing.
It’s the idea that regulation can be solved with a single instruction in the middle of nervous-system overwhelm.

The nervous system isn’t just responding to “this moment”

When a child is dysregulated, their body isn’t only reacting to what just happened.

It’s holding:
– their whole day
– their whole week
– sensory overload
– emotional stress
– past experiences
– and patterns stored in the body over time

All of that lives in the nervous system.

So when we say “take a deep breath,” we’re often asking the body to do something it doesn’t yet have the capacity for.

This is something my yoga training helped me understand deeply.

Yoga doesn’t view humans as just a mind inside a body.
It sees us as layered beings — physical, energetic, emotional, mental, and intuitive — all communicating at once.

And regulation happens when those layers are supported together.

Yoga taught me that breath is a relationship, not a quick fix

In yoga, breathwork (pranayama) isn’t something we jump into randomly.

Traditionally, the body is prepared first through:
– movement (asana)
– pressure and proprioceptive input
– rhythm and repetition
– grounding and sensory support

It is then when we can work consciously with the breath.

Why?

Because breath interacts with everything — muscles, tissues, nerves, energy pathways, emotions, and memory.

Through yogic frameworks like the panchamaya kosha system, we understand that experience is layered:

  • Annamaya kosha – the physical body
  • Pranamaya kosha – the energetic body (breath, vitality)
  • Manomaya kosha – the emotional and unconscious mind
  • Vijnanamaya kosha – discernment and insight
  • Anandamaya kosha – connection and integration

When stress is held in the body, it’s not just physical tension, it’s energetic, emotional, and relational.

A single deep breath can’t undo all of that.

But a relationship with breath, built slowly and gently, can.

How this understanding changed the way I parent (and teach)

Becoming a parent added another layer of learning.

I paired my yoga training with:
– child development research
– nervous system science
– gentle parenting principles
– trauma-aware practice
– and lived experience with real children and real life

What I saw again and again was this:

Children don’t regulate by being told what to do.
They regulate through felt experience.

Through:
– pushing into the ground
– moving big energy first
– playful repetition
– co-regulation with a safe adult
– and practices that make sense to their body

That’s why in my work with families:
– we don’t start with “take a deep breath”
– we meet the body where it is
– we use movement, pressure, rhythm, and play
– and we introduce breath in ways that feel accessible and safe

Sometimes breath comes later.
Sometimes it comes quietly.
Sometimes it comes through imagination, sound, a game or using props.

And sometimes, the most regulating thing isn’t breath at all… it’s connection.

What actually helps children regulate

From both yoga philosophy and parenting practice, I’ve learned this:

Regulation is not a technique.
It’s a capacity.

And capacity is built through:
– repetition
– safety
– connection
– and experiences that the nervous system can integrate

This is why playful, embodied practices work so well.

Not because they distract children from their feelings
but because they help the body process them.

Over time, children learn:
– what different states feel like
– how their body moves between them
– and which tools help them come back into balance

Eventually, breath becomes one of those tools
but not because we forced it.

Because the body learned it could trust it.

A different invitation

So instead of asking:
“Why won’t breathing work?”

I invite parents to ask:

“What is my child’s body holding right now?”
“What support does their nervous system need first?”

Sometimes that looks like:
– movement before stillness
– play before quiet
– connection before instruction

This is the lens I bring to family yoga.
Not watered-down yoga.
Not quick fixes.

But practices that honour the whole human experience —
body, breath, emotions, energy, and relationship.

Because real regulation isn’t something we demand.

It’s something we grow into, together.

Come and practice with me inside of the Family Yoga Vault. A journey to support your families well-being packed with supportive resources to play with and explore together.

Check it out here:

The Family Yoga Vault

Latest Posts:

Leave a comment

Comments

Leave a comment